Discover the benefits of making your own toothpaste with this easy, homemade remineralizing toothpaste recipe. Not only can it help reverse tooth decay, but itโs also a simple, natural alternative to store-bought options.

I never imagined Iโd become someone who makes all her personal care and beauty products from scratch. Back in the day, I used to grab soaps, shampoos, lotions, and toothpaste without a second thought, just like Iโd pick up a box of cheese-flavored crackers. But things have changed, and now I make all our soaps and lotions at home. One product, however, remained store-boughtโour toothpaste. I was content with fluoride-free options and didnโt think twice about it.
Then, in one of my typical deep dives into research, I stumbled upon something remarkable: making your own toothpaste is not only easy but can also contribute to reversing tooth decay. Reverse tooth decay? Yes, you heard that right! It might sound surprising, but it makes sense. Just as our bodies have incredible healing capabilities, so do our teeth. Why wouldnโt they benefit from the same natural healing power?
Let me tell you, this homemade toothpaste has surpassed any store-bought brand Iโve tried. It leaves my teeth feeling naturally cleaner, my breath fresher, and itโs actually helping to reverse dental decay. Can you believe it? Our teeth are getting brighter and healthier with just a few short weeks of using this paste. My oldest daughter loves it, while my youngest isnโt quite on board yet. Iโm working on a more child-friendly flavor for her, so stay tuned for that!
If youโre looking for healthier teeth or want to address a cavity without resorting to drilling and filling, itโs absolutely possible. Start by embracing a whole foods dietโcheck out my previous posts for tips on making that transition. The Weston A. Price Foundation also offers fantastic guidance on nutrition and dental health. Combine a nutrient-dense diet with this incredible homemade toothpaste and a bit of oil pulling (more on that soon), and youโll be on your way to a healthier smile. Your teeth will thank you!
Homemade Remineralizing Toothpaste
Ingredients:
Coconut Oil: Acts as the base for the toothpaste, providing a smooth texture and helping to bind the other ingredients. It has antimicrobial properties that support oral health.
Baking Soda: Gently cleans and polishes teeth, helping to remove surface stains and neutralize acids in the mouth.
Bentonite Clay: Absorbs toxins and helps to detoxify the mouth. It also provides a gritty texture that aids in cleaning.
Calcium Carbonate Powder: Supplies calcium, which is essential for strengthening tooth enamel and supporting overall dental health.
Magnesium Powder: Contributes to the remineralization process by supplying magnesium, which works with calcium to strengthen and rebuild tooth enamel.
Stevia Extract: Adds a touch of natural sweetness to the toothpaste without contributing to tooth decay.
Peppermint Essential Oil: Provides a fresh, pleasant flavor and has natural antibacterial properties that help to freshen breath and support oral hygiene.
Directions:
Soften the Coconut Oil: If your coconut oil is hard, gently warm it in a small saucepan until it reaches a softened butter consistency. It doesnโt need to be fully melted, just soft enough to mix.
Mix Ingredients: Combine all ingredients with the softened coconut oil and stir thoroughly. Avoid using metal utensils or containers as bentonite clay reacts with metal, which can reduce its effectiveness. Use plastic, silicone, or glass instead.
Transfer to Container: Pour the mixture into your squeeze tube or glass jar. For best results, use a small amount each time you brush.
Tips for Success:
- Storage: If you choose to use a glass jar, consider using a popsicle stick or a small spatula to scoop out the toothpaste. This keeps the paste clean and prevents contamination.
- Adjusting Flavor: If you prefer a different flavor, try experimenting with essential oils such as spearmint or cinnamon. Just be sure to use oils that are safe for oral use.
- Consistency: If the toothpaste is too thick, you can add a little more coconut oil. If itโs too runny, add a bit more bentonite clay.
- Routine: For optimal results, pair this toothpaste with a whole foods diet and regular oil pulling to support overall oral health.
- Children's Preferences: If your kids are picky about flavors, start with small amounts of essential oils and taste-test until you find a blend they like. You might also try adding a small amount of xylitol for a sweeter taste.
Isnโt it amazing how simple it is to make your own toothpaste? It takes just a few minutes to whip up a batch. Though the ingredients might be a bit of an investment, they make a large quantity of toothpaste, so youโll be set for a while. When you run out, just make a new batch, and youโre all set!
Have you ever tried making your own toothpaste? I hope this encourages you to give it a go!
๐ Recipe
Homemade Remineralizing Toothpaste
Make your own toothpaste at home with this easy recipe! This natural, remineralizing toothpaste combines simple ingredients for a fresh, healthier smile. Perfect for those seeking a DIY dental care solution.
Materials
- โ cup coconut oil (softened, not fully melted)
- ยฝ tablespoon baking soda
- 1 tablespoon bentonite clay
- 1 ยฝ teaspoons calcium carbonate powder
- 1 ยฝ teaspoons magnesium powder
- ยผ teaspoon stevia extract (pure)
- 10 drops peppermint essential oil
Tools
- Small saucepan (for softening coconut oil)
- Non-metal mixing bowl
- Plastic, silicone, or glass stirring utensil
- Squeeze tube or glass jar (for storage)
- Popsicle stick or small spatula (if using a glass jar)
Instructions
- Soften Coconut Oil: Warm coconut oil in a small saucepan until it reaches a softened butter consistency. It should be soft but not completely melted.
- Mix Ingredients: In a non-metal bowl, combine softened coconut oil with baking soda, bentonite clay, calcium carbonate powder, magnesium powder, stevia extract, and peppermint essential oil. Stir thoroughly.
- Transfer to Container: Pour the mixture into a squeeze tube or glass jar. Use a small amount each time you brush.





April J Harris says
I have never made my own toothpaste - I found this post so interesting! Thank you for sharing it with our Hearth and Soul Hop. Sharing!
Danielle McCoy says
It's better than the fluoride and glycerine laden stuff at the store. Much healthier for your teeth! We already avoided fluoride, but glycerine is even in most "natural" toothpastes and glycerine eats tooth enamel. So, we make our own. I love it!
Pam C says
Where did you buy the magnesium? In what form? I see mag citrate, mag oxide...
Which is best for toothpaste?
Danielle McCoy says
I bought the magnesium at the local health food store. It's magnesium citrate. Natural calm, to be exact. You can find it on amazon as well.
Krista says
Your links to the items are no longer working?
Also, is the stevia for flavor or does it add something important? I am not a stevia fan.
Danielle McCoy says
Hi Krista,
Thanks for pointing out the broken links! They should all be in working order now, sorry about that! As for the stevia it is purely for flavor. This stuff doesn't taste particularly good, the peppermint helps and the stevia just adds a bit of sweetness. My kids won't use it without it. Some people prefer xylitol (I don't care for it) and you can definitely use it sans sweetener if you'd like.
Krista says
Thanks, Danielle, I am excited to try this!
Rhonda Burke says
I make one with cinnamon and orange oil. The orange oil is sweet enough that you don't need sweetener.
Kendra says
Just made it! It is very soft and I noticed it easily ran out of our mouths, especially my 4 year olds. Should it be refrigerated? Tastes good to us! My teeth were noticeably whiter after 1 use. Thank you!